City Oltra

4.8(470)

Shop 11/1 Eddy Ave, Haymarket, New South Wales, 2000

Call Now Website Google Maps

Services:Dine-InTakeaway

Good ValueGenerous Toppings

Known for

Wheelchair accessible

Why Choose City Oltra?

City Oltra has built genuine local loyalty around two distinct pizza styles: a traditional thin New York crust and a celebrated square deep-dish with fluffy dough and crisp, cheesy edges. The service is a real draw, staff make regulars feel genuinely welcomed and offer solid recommendations, and the menu extends well beyond basics, with standouts like the potato and sausage pizza and Bianca with hot honey delivered at fair prices.

About City Oltra

City Oltra in Haymarket has earned a serious name among Sydney pizza lovers, and it's easy to see why once you've sat down for a feed. They do two very different styles here, and both have their devotees: a traditional thin New York style and a thicker square deep-dish style that regulars rave about for its fluffy dough and crisp, cheesy edges. People come back again and again for that square pizza, with its airy crust and ultra-crisp base, and the toppings range well beyond the usual. The potato and sausage comes up as a standout, and locals mention the Bianca with hot honey, the Rancho, the Diavola, and the smoked peppers with buffalo mozzarella and fresh basil as flavours you won't find on every corner.

You can order a whole pizza or grab slices on their own, which makes it a good spot to bring a group and try a few things. Word around Haymarket is that the toppings are generous (one pizza comfortably feeds two), and the prices are seen as fair for the size and the location. Don't skip the sides: the crumbed olives get a lot of love, as does the garlic bread and the house-made ice cream sandwich for afters. There's a beer and wine selection too, and we hear they can mix a decent cocktail.

What really keeps people coming back, beyond the food, is the service. Staff here are known for being warm, knowledgeable and happy to recommend without any pressure, and the room has a fun, relaxed atmosphere with good tunes. They've looked after coeliac diners with a gluten-free base that gets glowing mentions, and they'll split bills at the time of order. It can get noisy at peak times, and the menu is focused rather than sprawling, so bear that in mind.

City Oltra offers dine-in and takeaway, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and seating. They're not open every day, so check the hours before you head in.

Location

What Customers Say on Google

Value

“The square pizza has a nice fluffy dough and the crisp cheesy edges were really yummy…Prices were very fair given the size.”

Taste

“The pizzas are so delicious- in particular I love the Bianca pizza with the hot honey. The crust is super thin and crispy - one of my favourites all time.”

Staff

“Every single staff member i have interacted with here are lovely and helpful.”

Source: Google Reviews

Community Comments

No comments yet. Have you dealt with City Oltra? Be the first to leave a comment below.

Frequently Asked Questions About City Oltra

: City Oltra does two distinct styles: a traditional thin New York slice and a thicker square deep-dish pizza with a fluffy dough and crisp, cheesy edges. The square style has become the signature order, with regulars saying any topping on it works well. Toppings go beyond the usual, with the potato and sausage and the Bianca with hot honey frequently mentioned as standouts.
: Yes, it is regularly called good value with generous portions, and one pizza is often enough to feed two people. Slices can also be ordered individually, which suits a group wanting to try a few styles. Diners mention fair pricing given the size of the pizzas, and the garlic bread and crumbed olives are popular add-ons worth sharing.
: City Oltra is closed Monday and Sunday, open Tuesday to Thursday from 4pm to 10pm, and Friday to Saturday from 4pm until midnight. It's tucked near Central station in Haymarket, so it suits an evening dine-in or takeaway pizza rather than a lunch stop. Check with the shop directly if you need a specific time confirmed.
: Yes, City Oltra offers both dine-in and takeaway. The venue is wheelchair accessible and has a dine-in atmosphere people enjoy, with staff often praised for friendly service and solid recommendations on pizza and drinks. It's a good option whether you want to eat in near Central station or grab pizza to go.
: Beyond the thin and square-style pizzas, City Oltra is known for sides like crumbed olives and garlic bread, plus a drinks list that includes beer, wine and cocktails. The atmosphere and staff are frequently highlighted, with many describing the service as warm and attentive even during busy periods near Central station.